The 34 best personalized jewelry gifts to surprise your loved ones with in 2023

Looking for a sweet, sentimental gift? Well, the best personalized jewelry gifts are the perfect way to make your loved ones feel like they're truly one-of-a-kind. 

Whether it’s an initial, birthstone, meaningful charm or engraved message, personalized jewelry makes for a keepsake that will be loved and treasured for years to come. Customized gifts are the perfect way to show your recipient you've gone the extra mile for their present and didn't wait until the last minute to organize their gift. 

With more and more jewelry brands offering bespoke services, there's a whole host of beautiful designs that can be personalized to your specifications. We've scoured the internet to find the best personalized jewelry gifts of all kinds - from chic signet rings to dainty engraved bracelets. There’s something to suit every style and every budget in our list, whether you're looking for the best 60th birthday gifts for mom or unique gifts for men, you'll find a present they'll love and wear for many years below.

Best personalized jewelry gifts to buy in 2023

Where to buy personalized jewelry gifts

• Amazon: Personalized and engraved jewelry available at low prices
• Astrid & Miyu: Engraved rings, pendants and bracelets in various styles
• Edge of Ember: Sustainable jewelry including birthstone earrings and necklaces
• Etsy: Unique and bespoke pieces including engravable necklaces, earrings and more
• Mejuri: Investment pieces that make for a meaningful gift
• Missoma: Stylish necklaces, bracelets and rings that can be customized
• Monica Vinader: Best for elegant pieces that make a statement
• Nordstrom: Zodiac and engravable jewelry for adults and children
• Not On The High Street: A haven of personalized jewelry gifts to suit everyone
• Orelia: Best for affordable jewelry gifts that look expensive
• Pandora: Surprise her with gorgeous birthstone rings and iconic charm bracelets
• Selfridges: Shop more exclusive brands for rare pieces
• Wolf & Badger: Engravable and zodiac pieces from independent brands

Personalized jewelry gifts for her

It doesn't get any more personal than a necklace that representing their birth month, and this Missoma necklace proves that. We love the unique ridge design that borders the gorgeous birthstone star. It's a piece that would make for one of the best 18th birthday gifts if you're looking to treat your daughter, granddaughter or niece to something special.

And to make this custom necklace even more one-of-a-kind, you can add a sweet message on the back for free. 

If simple gold or silver jewelry isn’t quite their bag, PDPAOLA have a colorful solution. Their initial necklaces are glistening with a combination of different stones that catch the light beautifully.

The chain is adjustable, meaning you can switch up the length depending on the neckline you’re wearing or even layer it with other necklaces. If you're looking for impressive 30th birthday gifts that don't cost the world, then this could be a great option.

Another way to make the classic initial pendant more exciting is with this rainbow-studded option from Edge of Ember. Made from recycled sterling silver and plated with 18-carat gold, this unique pendant features small semi-precious gemstones dotted around whichever letter you choose, including garnet, peridot, amethyst and Swiss blue topaz. Pair it with a simple gold chain or a charm bracelet and you’ve got a perfect sustainable gift. All Edge of Ember products come with a one-year warranty - another bonus. 

Keep it simple and cute with this double initial pendant necklace. Whether it's their initial or yours, they'll love wearing those special letters close to their heart. This custom necklace comes in recycled sterling silver and 18k gold. And with the initials hanging at two different lengths, this subtle yet unique necklace will definitely draw eyes. It's the perfect personalized gift for the minimal giftee who likes to keep things classy and simple.

These 18 carat gold-plated hoops are a subtle way to incorporate a birthstone personalization - though some months are out of stock, they’ll likely be restocked. The hoops are available in silver and gold, and the thick but small shape means that they’re perfect both for stacking alongside other earrings, and for wearing on their own.

There are gift wrapping options available, including a recyclable gift box free of charge, and the hoops are made from recycled sterling silver, so you won’t be harming the planet, either.

If you’re looking for zodiac gifts to give a loved one, look no further than these unique earrings. They’re hand-finished for an even more personalized touch; just choose the desired star sign, and there’s a three-year warranty to give you peace of mind. Not only do the 18 carat gold-plated studs reflect the constellations of certain zodiac signs, they’re decorated with gemstones such as rose quartz, malachite, mother of pearl and tiger eye.

Why not go all out with a personalized necklace including their entire name or yours? Edge of Ember allows you to tap into your creative side and customize this 18K gold necklace with up to eight letters. And if their name is over eight letters, you can still personalize the necklace with a name that's meaningful to them. 

If you’d rather personalize a jewelry gift with a memorable date than with a zodiac sign or name, this simple silver necklace features a medium size chain made from 100% recycled sterling silver, but is also available in gold, if you know your loved one favors gold jewelry. Personalize this necklace with a special date, for example an anniversary, and you’ve got the perfect gift that’s unique but still affordable.

Each elegant ring is made to order using silversmithing techniques making this a truly one-of-a-kind gift as no two of these rings will be exactly the same. A variety of ring sizes are available, including half sizes on request. We love the organic shape of these rings and the fact that each piece is completely bespoke and unique to them.

If you prefer your personalization to be more subtle - even indiscernible to others - these silver earrings can be personalized with just one letter, number or symbol. Choose from a variety of fonts and engrave your loved ones’ initial, or a number that holds value for you both. Made from sterling silver, one of these minimal hoops features a small heart, and they’re also available in an 18 carat gold-plated version.

Gift your loved one a personalized necklace and earrings in one fell swoop with this set from Astrid & Miyu. Presented in a gorgeous gift box, the set includes the brand’s Zodiac Pendant Necklace, personalized with your desired star sign, and Cosmic Star Stud Earrings, and is available in either a silver or gold finish.

Also included in the set is a card with a description of your loved ones’ zodiac sign and its qualities, and you can choose to add gift wrapping, including a personalized message, for an extra special touch.

If your friend or family member is more of a bangle fan, this understated initial bracelet is handcrafted with sterling silver, covered with 22 carat gold, and features dazzling white cubic zirconia. This gorgeous bangle definitely makes a statement, but is delicate enough to be worn alongside plenty of other jewelry, and for any occasion. If you’re looking for a custom gift that won’t break the bank but still looks expensive, you’re in luck.

At a slightly higher price point but still supremely affordable for a high-quality necklace, this simple zodiac chain features a pendant personal to each star sign, with handset, and white cut diamonds of 0.2 carats adorning the pendant. All star signs are available, with a gold option too, but we love this understated silver option, which arrives in a black and gold jewelry box and is ethically sourced and handmade.

One way to combine the personalized aspects of both a loved ones’ initial and their birth month is with this dual necklace from Edge of Ember, which features a small birthstone pendant and an initial pendant, both sat onto a unique gold ball chain. Made from recycled sterling silver and plated in 18 carat gold, there are two chain lengths available to choose from, meaning you can adapt the necklace to your loved ones’ preferences.

For something a bit different, this bracelet would suit someone who likes to stack chunky bracelets on their wrists, or as a simple but eye-catching accessory to be worn alone.

The thick bar on the bracelet can be engraved for free, and since the bar will usually face inwards towards the wrist, there’s a more personal aspect to the engraving option. This bracelet is available in a silver, gold or rose gold finish, but we particularly like the unique rose gold.

Liberty is renowned for its varied offering of jewelry, which includes stand-out pieces from high-end designers, as well as vintage treasures. The heritage department store has launched an own-brand collection of 9 carat gold initial signet rings, and they couldn’t be more perfect for gifting. Designed to be worn on the pinky finger and featuring the iconic Arts and Crafts Liberty typography, each ring is made to order and handcrafted in Italy.

Sometimes less is more, and this simple 14k personalized necklace will make a significant gift for the gal who likes to keep things minimal. Whether she wears it with her favorite loungewear or cocktail dress, this gorgeous necklace will complement any outfit. And although this necklace isn't the most affordable, they'll be able to rock it without experiencing any tarnish. Plus, who would say no to 14k gold?

For the giftee who loves everything astrology. This gorgeous and chic gold bracelet features a mini heart-shaped birthstone. It's the perfect dainty everyday accessory they can wear with any outfit. And no need to worry about taking a trip to the store for a gift bag. This personalized bracelet is housed inside sustainable luxury packaging, or for just $5/£5 more, you can add a personalized gift bag and give them the best zodiac gift. 

No one will turn down a personalized ring of their birthstone, especially when it's from Pandora. With a sterling silver beaded band and a centered stone in their birthday month's color, they'll look forward to wearing this simple yet thoughtful gift every day. And if you're looking for a sweet 21st birthday gift idea, consider this one.

She'll be smiling from ear to ear when she sees the teal blue Tiffany box. The iconic Return to Tiffany Lovestruck Heart Tag Necklace is engravable and can be customized with your gift recipient's initials for an additional $55, but if you want to make it even more personable, you can have it engraved by hand for $75 more. Every lady I know who owns this gorgeous heart tag necklace rocks it around their neck every day. It's a personalized necklace that matches all their outfits and other accessories no matter the occasion.

Engraved jewellery for him

Signet rings have become so popular in the past few years because they're one of those stylish unisex pieces that look equally good on men as they do on women. This sleek Missoma version is a tad more understated than the usual, so is great for those who don't like to draw too much attention to their jewelry. It also comes in silver for those who prefer silver jewelry.

A tag necklace is a must for any fashion-forward men who want something simple around the neck. This Mejuri version is certainly an investment piece, but it would make for a much-appreciated present that will last him for years to come. A lovely anniversary present, or if you're stuck for a good Valentine's Day gift for him.

A classic bracelet that would make a lovely gift for anyone who prefers understated jewelry, this band also has plenty of space for a meaningful engraving. It also comes in gold for anyone whose skin tone suits that better. Or if you're struggling to choose between them, check our guide on what colors suits me to see which skin tones go best with which metal. This is a great price for a sleek piece of men's jewelry.

A striking but elegantly classic signet ring, this titanium ring is a gift that he will love. It's handcrafted and can be engraved with any initial to make a real statement. There is also the option to engrave it with lower case letters, which is something we haven't seen at many retailers.

Monica Vinader has long been recognized as the destination for jewelry with a thoughtful twist. The Norfolk-based brand offers personalization service on several of its best-selling designs, and the intuitive website means it’s easy and quick to bespoke a piece.

The sleek bar on this stylish bracelet can be engraved with any name or message of your choosing and the adjustable cords are a practical bonus. There are also different cord colors and metal types to choose from so that you can customize this to suit whoever you're buying for.

If you've already got him one of the best smartwatches but he fails to put it away tidily everyday, this watch case could make a useful gift. It comes with three sections for his watch and any additional attachments it might need and it can be personalized with his initials for an extra special touch.

This unisex signet ring has a unique oval shape, and is much slimmer than signet rings tend to be. For this reason, it would be a great gift for someone who needs to wear more understated or practical jewelry for their job. The sterling silver ring is plated with 18 carat gold, and is hand finished for an even more unique touch. Personalize the ring’s oval center with a name, date, or anything else that holds meaning for you and your loved one.

This simple and sleek Monica Vinader bracelet is made with 100% recycled gold vermeil and sterling silver. Add a special text, a mixture of text and motifs, or just a motif symbol on the inside or outside of the bar. And if silver isn't their vibe, this bracelet also comes in gold and rose gold. 

Either choose an icon to be engraved onto this hexagon pendant - one for each zodiac sign is available, along with a star, a heart, or a lightning bolt - or add your own text, for example a loved ones’ initials. This ridged pendant sits on a chunky gold chain, which is made from stainless steel and PVD gold.

Another affordable option from Orelia London, this bracelet features a chunky chain and an engravable bar, which you can choose up to 11 letters or digits to personalize. Made from stainless steel, this durable bracelet will last your loved one for years to come and will go with any outfit - including any other silver jewelry they might wear. And if you're shopping for a picky dad, consider this one of the best gifts for dad. It's a simple yet thoughtful gift that'll truly make him feel one-of-a-kind.

Whether it be their initials or your anniversary date, some giftees aren't keen on having their jewelry plastered in numbers or text. However, this stainless steel chain bracelet still allows you to give them a unique piece of jewelry in a subtle way. You can add his two initials on the clasp for just $19/£15 more. 

The Lucleon 8MM Gold-Tone Stainless Steel Curb Chain Bracelet is great for everyday wear. He can rock it to the office or on a night out with the guys. But before heading out, every time he clasps his bracelet, he won't be able to help but think of you.

Keep things nice, sleek, and zodiac filled with this gunmetal stainless steel dog tag necklace. If he isn't a fan of high-neck jewelry, this necklace lays against the lower chest, making it the perfect option. And if you want to add a bit more customization, you can personalize the back with his name or a significant date for $19/£15 more. Plus, it'll be great to bring a unique black accessory piece to his jewelry box. 

Looking for personalized jewelry gifts for husbands? Look no further. This stunning Tiffany & Co. signet ring is a simple, quality piece that can be customized with his initials or a meaningful symbol at an additional cost of $55. He'll be lost for words when he pulls out a Tiffany blue box. 

Personalized jewelry doesn't have to cost a fortune, not even $30. For less than $26/£26, you can surprise your loved one with this engraved leather braided bracelet with up to five names. So whether you want to add both of your names or your entire family's, he'll wear this personalized bracelet around his wrist proudly. 

How to choose the best personalized jewelry gifts

Choosing a personalized jewelry gift shouldn’t be too different than choosing a jewelry gift of any kind - most of us would agree that the best gifts to receive are those that speak to our individual interests, making us feel that a lot of thought has gone into the gift choice. 

When it comes to personalized jewelry gifting, this is no different. The first step should be to consider what sort of jewelry your loved one already owns, wears and loves. If you’ve noticed that every piece of their daily jewelry collection is silver, it might be rogue to branch out to a gold item - however, if they’ve been known to occasionally sport a gold ring or pair of earrings, it might be worth the risk. Similarly, if your loved one tends to sway towards understated, simple pieces, it’s probably not wise to opt for a large pair of earrings or a chunky bangle.

A piece of personalized jewelry that features your loved ones’ zodiac sign is a good route to go down, and this will be an even more special gift if you know that they’re already into astrology, or feel particularly connected to their sign. A zodiac or birthstone piece of jewelry is a great way to add a personalized touch to a gift for someone you might be not be related to or life-long friends with. Someone’s star sign or birth month is a little less, well, personal than a loving message engraved into a bracelet or necklace, so this is a great option for those trickier gifts to choose, such as a partner’s family member or a colleague. Just make sure you’re 100% sure of their birth month or star sign before you invest!

Whoever you’re buying for, they’re sure to appreciate the extra thought that goes into the personalization of jewelry for a loved one. Most brands offer a gift wrapping option, too, sometimes for no extra cost.

How much does it cost to have custom jewelry made?

It all depends on the material, brand, designer, and item you're buying. When it comes to a unique, personalized gift, you'll naturally generally pay more as you are purchasing a one-of-a-kind present. The price tag for custom jewelry can range anywhere from £25/$25 for a personalized chain bracelet from Trendhim to £600/$700 for a 14k solid gold tag necklace from Mejuri, it all depends on the level of personalization and materials.