Best Christmas cake 2020: The woman&home taste test
You deserve only the best Christmas cake on your festive table this year and these are the Test Kitchen’s top picks.

Our Christmas cake recipes are easy to prepare ahead of time but we understand that not everyone wants to bake their own festive showstopper. To help you pick the best Christmas cake for you, and your loved, we’ve ensured there is a good variety to choose from.
From cakes with no icing, classic bakes with marzipan and fondant as well as a trio of smaller cakes that includes a golden sponge and a chocolate cake there is something for every palate. We’ve taste-tested hundreds of Christmas fare to help you deliver the ultimate festive feast. Whether you’re looking for the best Christmas canapés, puddings or more, read our woman&home Christmas taste test to discover the full list of winners for 2020.
Best Christmas cake 2020: The winners
Betty's Royal Iced Bell Christmas Cake, 1kg
£25. Bursting with plump sherry-infused vine fruits and natural glacé cherries, this cake feels grown-up and sophisticated. We liked the minimal icing and the gorgeous hand-stencilled bell design. When cutting the cake, Bettys recommend using a sharp serrated knife and a sawing action if you want to achieve the best slices.
M&S Chocolate Fruit & Nut Cake, 800g
£15. Rich and buttery, this cake was made for the self-confessed chocolate lovers out there. Chocolate lovers rejoice. It’s packed with fruit, nuts and a dash of indulgent chocolate liqueur. To decorate the cake, which serves 12, M&S have used chocolate flavoured sauce, sweetened dried cranberries, candied orange slices and more nuts!
Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Holly Wreath Christmas Cake, 900g
£11. The design on this cake is simple, understated and chic, which we loved but it helps that it tastes fantastic too. There is a good balance of icing to marzipan with neither overpowering the other. It’s rich, moist and full of flavour thanks to the infusion of brandy and variety of fruit inside.
Tesco Finest Rich Fruit Cake, 907g
£10. Marvellously light in texture but bold in flavour thanks to the addition of oak-aged brandy and Cognac. This Christmas fruit cake is festively spiced and packed with juicy vine fruits and the classic glace cherries. For uniform slices, it’s recommended that you clean the knife after each cut. Plus, if you’re a Tesco Clubcard holder and you buy the cake before the 7 December, it will only cost you £7.50.
Aldi Specially Selected Luxury All Over Iced Cake, 1kg
£6.99 - Available in store. The subtle shimmer on this chic cake design makes it worthy of a spot on any Christmas table. We enjoyed the good even layers of icing and marzipan which cover a rich, spiced fruit cake. This cake would be good for the whole family as even though it’s infused with brandy, the taste of alcohol isn’t prominent. At under £7, we thought this cake was excellent value for money.
Waitrose Trio of Christmas Cakes
£35. Not only does this cake have an adorable festive design, it’s perfect for families where everyone wants something different! There’s a classic Christmas cake with brandy-soaked fruit and a generous layer of icing and marzipan, a chocolate sponge and a golden sponge with raspberry jam and vanilla buttercream.
Best Christmas Cake of 2020: The honourable mentions
Despite not making the top selections in our taste test, these Christmas cakes are certainly worth a try. These cakes are a little less conventional but still impressed our team of taste testers on flavour.
Co-op Shimmering Iced Christmas Cake, 907g
£8. There is a nice variety of fruit in this classic cake and we particularly enjoyed the abundance of cherries. We admired the simplicity of the hand-decorated design, which makes it an easy addition to any festive setting. Our taste testers thought the sponge was moist and moreish but perhaps a little sweet for some. The cake is suitable for vegetarians.
Country Fare Brandy Fruit Cake, 1kg
£25. Decadently topped with nuts and cherries, this luxury cake is perfect for those who don’t like icing or marzipan but still want something special for their centrepiece. The cake is suitable for vegetarians and is hand-fed with French brandy. It has a very crumbly texture and would be the perfect partner to a hot pot of tea.
Asda Extra Special Brandy Soaked Fully Iced Fruit Cake, 907g:
£9. The gold and bronze tones in the decoration for this cake make it look truly special. The fruit cake contains all the classics you’d expect such as sultanas, raisins and glacé cherries. There’s also French brandy, candied citrus peel, split almonds and chopped walnuts in the mix. The edible sugar decorations sit on top of even layers of marzipan and icing for a lovely festive finish.
Daylesford Organic Christmas cake, 800g:
£18, Ocado. Made by hand using an old family recipe, this simple Christmas cake might not have any showstopping decorations but it’s packed with fruit, spices and soaked in brandy. If you wanted, you could ice and decorate the cake yourself and it’s then at least half-homemade! Another interesting and impressive feature of the cake is that 20% of the electricity used to bake it was generated using solar panels on their organic farm in the Cotswolds! We also really like the tin which can be re-used to keep other treats in once the cake has been eaten.
-
-
7 celeb-inspired straightener hairstyles we're loving for 2021
Look no further: These straightener hairstyles have got you covered for smooth, shiny, star-powered locks.
By Courtney Leiva •
-
How to get rid of fruit flies for good in five easy steps
Follow this simple plan of action to ensure the tiny buzzing pests don’t ruin your summer
By Helen Booth •
-
Best Easter drinks 2021: The woman&home taste test
These are the best drinks to celebrate the Easter weekend - as chosen by our expert food team
By Samuel Goldsmith •
-
Best Easter dinner food: The woman&home taste test
Our food team have selected their expert picks for the best Easter dinner yet
By Jessica Ransom •
-
Best white chocolate Easter eggs 2021: The woman&home taste test
Our expert food team pick out the best white chocolate Easter eggs in the shops this year
By Jessica Ransom •
-
Best milk chocolate Easter eggs 2021: The woman&home taste test
Milk chocolate is a classic Easter egg flavour but which buys were ranked top by our expert food team this year?
By Samuel Goldsmith •
-
Best dark chocolate Easter eggs 2021: The woman&home taste test
Like a bit of dark chocolate? These are the best Easter eggs to buy this year
By Rose Fooks •
-
Best vegan Easter eggs 2021: The woman&home taste test
These delicious vegan Easter eggs mean no one has to miss out!
By Jessica Ransom •
-
Best kids' Easter eggs 2021: The woman&home taste test
These are our top picks for kids' Easter eggs as selected by our expert Test Kitchen team
By Samuel Goldsmith •
-
Best Easter eggs 2021: The woman&home taste test
Our expert food team have tested the best Easter eggs in the shops this year - see what made their list
By Jessica Ransom •