Wondering how Nigella Lawson and Paul Hollywood will work? Mary Berry weighs in on the new judges' dynamic

The verdict is in: Mary Berry shares how well Nigella Lawson and Paul Hollywood might get on in the GBBO tent

Mary Berry attends the RHS Chelsea Flower Show on May 22, 2025 in London
(Image credit: Getty Images)

Nigella Lawson taking over judging duties on Bake Off has been dominating the news, in the wake of Prue Leith announcing her departure from the long-running baking show.

However, many of the show's fans have been wondering how the dynamic will work between Nigella and existing judge, Paul Hollywood.

Nigella Lawson, attends a book signing and lunch at the Melbourne restaurant, Taxi Kitchen, during her tour of Australia

(Image credit: Fairfax Media/Getty Images)

It's therefore great news that Nigella has dropped huge hints she's planning to be both kind, and will be encouraging the contestants and viewers watching at home to remain passionate about baking.

She once told Now to Love that she isn't a fan of "mean" cooking shows, sharing that she finds this judging style to be "counterproductive for everyone."

"It makes people at home feel inhibited about cooking too, because they have this persecutory voice in their heads. I couldn’t be part of a programme like that," she explains, concluding, "It doesn’t mean to say you’re not honest, but there’s never a need to be mean."

Although it hasn't been revealed whether Mary has, or is planning to speak to Nigella personally about her new role, she did have a conversation with Prue Leith when she originally joined Bake Off as a judge, allegedly offering a warning about Paul.

According to The Mirror, Prue spoke about the conversation she had with Mary during an appearance on the Spooning with Mark Wogan podcast.

Prue explained that she phoned Mary to ask her "whether Paul Hollywood was workable with," knowing Mary would "tell me the truth."

Prue says, "She was very interesting, she said 'do you know what? He is so good and he is very good at his job and he knows baking backwards, he's a lovely guy and very friendly and easy to work with'."

It's said that Mary continued, "But, he knows so much and he's so knowledgeable, he doesn't need you at all. You have to just hold your own and push yourself in because he'll just do the show without you."

We're sure Nigella will be able to hold her own in the same way as Prue did, and we can't wait to see her step into her judging shoes when the next series of Bake Off arrives.

Lucy Wigley
Entertainment Writer

Lucy is a multi-award nominated writer and blogger with seven years’ experience writing about entertainment, parenting and family life. Lucy worked as a freelance writer and journalist at the likes of PS and moms.com, before joining GoodtoKnow as an entertainment writer, and then as news editor. The pull to return to the world of television was strong, and she was delighted to take a position at woman&home to once again watch the best shows out there, and tell you why you should watch them too.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.