How shoes should fit—everything you need to know for a comfortable, blister-free experience

Learning how shoes should fit will increase your everyday comfort levels and your confidence levels when shopping.

Lots of pretty shoes displayed in white boxes against a black background
(Image credit: Getty)

Understanding how shoes should fit will not only make a huge difference to your comfort levels but improve your all-around foot health. 

Rumour has it Marilyn Monroe once said “give the girl the right shoes and she can conquer the world”—a statement we’re inclined to agree with. Similarly, if you give a woman an ill-fitting, blister-inducing pair of shoes, then they’re likely to ruin her day.

We spend most of our waking hours wearing shoes, so it’s important to ensure they fit well. Failure to find a footwear with a spot-on fit can result in long term problems. Blisters and bunions shouldn’t be part-and-parcel of footwear you love, rather rare and mostly avoidable occurrences. 

Buying shoes in the correct size is a crucial starting point, as is taking into consideration the shape of your foot. Are your feet narrow or wide? Are your arches high or flat? For example, the best shoes for flat feet have a wide toe box, making extra space to avoid rubbing at the sides. It’s worth noting that this sizing guidance applies to all types of shoes, from the best sandals and boots to your trusted trainers. 

Fabric plays a big part in how shoes should fit too. Leather and canvas are durable, breathable options, and both will give the more you wear them. Plastic and vinyl shoes are neither breathable, nor stretchy, making them some of the main culprits of uncomfortable, ill-fitting shoes. 

How do you know if a shoe fits properly? 

“Your shoes should feel sturdy and comfortable and should fit both the length and width of your foot,”  explains Tony Gavin, leading podiatrist and founder of Osgo Healthcare (opens in new tab). “Your toes should have room to be able to wiggle freely. When trying on shoes, walk a little and take your time. Remember—if the shoes rub or pinch when trying them on, they’ll rub or pinch when you wear them.”

Laces, buckles and velcro straps will all help you to adjust the fit of your shoes, something that’s especially handy if you’re finding they’re just a little too big, but not quite roomy enough to need to size down. 

Shoes can be either too large or too small, and also too wide or too narrow. In some cases, the style of shoe may simply not be compatible with the shape of your foot. 

Key signs of an ill-fitting shoe are:

  • Pinching at the toes or heel
  • Pain when walking
  • Blisters
  • Bruising
  • Bunions 

How much room should be in the toe of a shoe?

Measuring the distance between the end of the shoe and your toe is a good marker of how shoes should fit. If possible, we’d recommend visiting a dedicated shoe store where a shop assistant can measure your feet and make suggestions based on your needs. This is especially important when shopping for running shoes or work shoes, as you’ll be wearing both for long stretches of time. 

“If you’re not able to get your feet measured, there should be a thumbs width at the end of the toe before the end of the shoe,” says Tony Gavin. “The toe box should be wide enough and deep enough for your toes. If you already suffer from a foot problem such as a bunion, you are advised to purchase extra side shoes or a shoe with depth.” Shoes with depth are extra roomy and make space for feet of all shapes. They can be purchased from specialist shops, which do charge a premium but are far cheaper than investing in custom orthotics. 

Lots of colourful shoes arranged in a path pattern on a white background

(Image credit: Getty)

What are the consequences of wearing shoes that don’t fit properly?

Ill-fitting shoes are at best uncomfortable, and at worst causing lasting damage to your feet. “Although genetics play a role in some structural problems in the feet, a shoe that doesn’t fit properly can certainly aggravate these conditions and in some cases make them worse,” advises Tony Gavin.

“One of the biggest problems caused by poorly-fitting shoes is blisters and the knock-on effect of these blisters,” adds Dr. Chris Morriss-Roberts, Head of Podiatry Operations at Margaret Dabbs London (opens in new tab). “They can cause thickening of the skin, and ongoing cracks and fissures in the skin of the feet depending on where the blisters are. If the blister is really severe, it can stop you from walking properly and most people find they start walking differently to compensate for the painful rubbing. In turn, this can cause back pain, knee pain or problems with your ankles.”

So far, so daunting. And that’s before we’ve even covered the potential havoc poorly-fitting shoes can wreak on your toenails. 

“Another problem that can be caused by shoes that fit incorrectly is Onycholysis, which is when the toenails drop off. When shoes are too tight, this can cause repetitive micro-traumas on the nails. These repetitive micro-traumas are caused by regularly wearing tight or ill-fitting shoes. Not only are missing toenails this painful and unsightly, but it can also have longer term consequences. Once a nail drops off, it is often never quite the same again.” 

If you’re noticing signs of any of these problems, we’d recommend visiting your GP or a podiatrist for guidance. 

How to find well fitting shoes

SHOES FOR NARROW FEET

If you have narrow feet… You likely have narrow feet if you find that you have excess space in your shoes around the edges. This can cause your feet to slip and slide around the inside of your shoe, which can cause rubbing and alter the way you walk. 

These brands are our top pick for anyone with narrow feet:

Shoes for narrow feet, Fashion Editor's picks

Image (opens in new tab)

Nike React Infinity Run Flyknit 2

RRP: $160/£144.95

Nike’s Flyknit upper hugs your feet, holding them firm with no slipping. This trainer is a great choice for road runners.


Image (opens in new tab)

Converse Color Chuck Taylor All Star Low-Top Shoe

RRP: $80/£52

Converse come up narrow as standard, so you can shop all styles with confidence. These pastel pumps are our top pick. 


Image (opens in new tab)

Each x Every Tie

RRP: $259/£190

Premium shoe label Each x Every offers a choice of three widths on all styles. These mules are ticking all our boxes for special occasions.


SHOES FOR WIDE FEET

If you have wide feet… Wide feet normally feel uncomfortable and caged in when wearing standard width shoes. You might feel as if your feet would spill out of the sides, or that you’re having to squish them into footwear. Wearing shoes that are too narrow will cause blisters and sores at the sides and tops of your feet. 

These brands are our top pick for anyone with wide feet:

Shoes for wide feet, Fashion Editor's picks


Image (opens in new tab)

New Balance Women’s 847v4

RRP: $134.99/£95

An extra wide footbed makes for an extra comfortable experience. They’re available in half sizes too, which is a handy touch. 


Image (opens in new tab)

M&S Collection Wide Fit Leather Tassel Boat Shoes

RRP: $77.50/£45

M&S offer a dedicated wide fit collection, brimming with everything from flats to sandals. These casual boat shoes would look great with jeans and a crisp oversized shirt. 


Image (opens in new tab)

Vionic Amy Wedge Sandal

RRP: $109.99/£100

Browse by wide fit to ensure a spot-on fit from Vionic. These wedges have the added benefit of a supportive and adjustable ankle strap. 


SHOES FOR FLAT FEET

If you have flat feet… Flat feet are characterised as having little to no arch, so that all of your foot is making contact with the ground. You should be able to tell if your feet are flat by looking at them, but examining your footprint is a good indication too. Flat arches mean your feet roll inwards when you walk, which can put pressure on your joints. 

These brands are our top pick for anyone with flat feet:

Shoes for flat feet, Fashion Editor's picks


Image (opens in new tab)

Brooks Adrenaline GTS 21 Women’s

RRP: $164/£120

Great for everyday runs, added support in the sole takes the strain off of your joints. We love the green shade too. 


Image (opens in new tab)

Clarks Un Cosmo Dress 

RRP: $130/£79

An elegant court shoe that would work just as well for work as it would play. The wide fit makes extra space for flat feet, while the block heel is super easy to walk in. 


Image (opens in new tab)

Hotter Java Sandals

RRP: $139/£85

A memory foam insole moulds to the shape of your foot for top-notch comfort. The buckle straps are easy to adjust. 


SHOES FOR HIGH ARCHES

If you have high arches… Again, like flat feet, you should be able to see if you have high arches by looking at your foot or footprint. High arches can cause problems as there’s less surface area to absorb shock and impact when walking or running. Seeking out shoes with extra cushioning will help ease any discomfort. 

These brands are our top pick for anyone with high arches:

Shoes for high arches, Fashion Editor's picks


Image (opens in new tab)

Asics Gel-Nimbus 23

RRP: $150/£155

Asics come up trumps when it comes to support, making them a smart investment for anyone with high arches. 


Image (opens in new tab)

Birkenstock Arizona Split

RRP: $170/£70

A specially moulded footbed ensures extra arch support as you walk, so your feet don’t ache by 12pm. We love this two-tone design. 


Image (opens in new tab)

FitFlop Rally Leather Trainers

RRP: $100/£80

Find it painful to wear flats? These trainers feature an anatomically contoured footbed to support the natural curves of your feet. 


Jess Beech is an experienced fashion and beauty editor, with more than eight years experience in the publishing industry. She has written for woman&home, GoodtoKnow, Now, Woman, Woman’s Weekly, Woman’s Own and Chat, and is a former Deputy Fashion & Beauty Editor at Future PLC. A beauty obsessive, Jess has tried everything from cryotherapy to chemical peels (minus the Samantha in Sex and The City-worthy redness) and interviewed experts including Jo Malone and Trinny Woodall.