60% of us have bought a gluten-free product. 15% of us are attempting to cut gluten out of our lives entirely. And more than half of us believe a gluten-free diet is healthier. After all, gluten’s detractors have linked it with everything from autism to Alzheimer’s disease. But actually, is gluten bad for you? We sort the facts from the fiction…
What is gluten?
Gluten is made up of two protein groups (gliadin and glutenin) which come together when flour and water are mixed to form dough. It’s found in whole grains like wheat, barley and rye.
What food has gluten?
Gluten is found in conventionally produced wheat products like bread, pasta, pizza, cakes and biscuits. It also lurks in beer, lager and barley squash, certain sweets and many pasta sauces, gravies and condiments like soy sauce.
Is gluten bad for you?
For most of us, gluten itself is neither intrinsically good nor bad, especially when consumed as part of a balanced diet. And many foods that contain gluten are actually very good for us.
However, for a small number, consuming gluten can have serious side effects. Coeliac disease, which means you a severe allegry to gluten, affects approximately 1 in 100 people in the UK. Sufferers have an allergic response to gluten which means that consuming tiny amounts, even a single breadcrumb, causes damage to the lining of the small intestine and hampers the absorption of nutrients, supressing growth and increasing the risk of anaemia, osteoporosis and certain cancers. Symptoms of a gluten allergy typically appear within a few hours of eating and may last for several days. They often include weight loss, fatigue, nausea, bloating, pain and mouth ulcers. Coeliac disease can be diagnosed with a blood test.
A further 13% of us are thought to have a gluten intolerance, or non-coeliac gluten sensitivity (NCGS). Signs of gluten intolerance include gastrointestinal sensitivity, joint pain and headaches. However, scientists believe that at least some of these symptoms may be caused by other proteins, yeast, pesticides or Fodmaps.
Gluten free diet benefits
But can a gluten free diet be good for you?
85-90% of those with coeliac disease are thought to be unaware of their condition. For those suffering from an undetected case of the illness, a gluten-free diet confers enormous health benefits. However, “at the moment, there is no evidence that going gluten free has any health benefit for anyone who does not have coeliac disease,” nutritionist Suzanne Anderegg cautions.
Adding naturally gluten-free grains such as quinoa, buckwheat, millet and amaranth to our diets whilst upping our intake of pulses, fruit and vegetables can have nutritional benefits. However, “people starting a gluten-free diet should aways seek advice from a professional Registered Dietitian or Registered Nutritionist,” says Sarah Jackson, who links the gluten-free trend with the Paleo Diet phenomenon. “The only benefits I see to this diet – and I say that with caution as I do not encourage cutting out grains, dairy, oils, legumes, sugar or salt – is that it may increase consumption of fish, nuts, fruit and vegetables, which are all great foods to include in our diets.”
The dangers of going gluten-free
That said, “going gluten-free excludes many nutritious foods from the diet,” argues nutritionist Claire Baseley. “Whole grains are a rich source of fibre, B vitamins and minerals such as iron and folate,” Suzanne expands. “There is much evidence to show that a diet rich in whole grains reduces the risk of heart disease, type 2 diabetes, obesity and some forms of cancer.” Sarah argues that any kind of ‘free from’ diet may, in fact, do you more harm than good unless you have an allergy or intolerance and seek professional advice.
You might be surprised to learn that gluten-free products often contain higher levels of fat, sugar and additives than their conventional counterparts. Far from being the ‘unhealthy’ option, scientists believe that foods such as wheat may, in fact, act as immune stimulants and natural prebiotics in non-coeliacs. Going gluten-free has been linked with weight gain, inflammation, insulin resistance, reductions in ‘good’ gut bacteria and immune cell function and increased levels of ‘bad’ gut bacteria, mercury and arsenic. It may even affect your memory.
Furthermore, Suzanne points out, gluten-free products are generally more expensive and less tasty. “And, as anyone who is coeliac will tell you, it is a lot of hard work and affects their entire life.” Why put yourself through it if you don’t have to? The so-called ‘clean eating’ trend can not only have negative nutritional consequences, argues Claire, but creates unnecessary fear and anxiety around food. “Food should be celebrated and enjoyed!” she exclaims. We couldn’t agree more.