We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article.
Pets love to misbehave, whether it’s making a mess or destroying your furniture. But a recent study conducted in late 2019 has suggested that ‘punishment-based’ training could be making them depressed.
According to the University of Porto, Portugal, dog training methods which involve shouting and scolding your dog, can result in negative consequences later in life such as depression.
Ana Catarina, study leader, used two groups of dogs. The first was dogs from reward-based dog training schools, which use food or play to encourage good behaviours.
The second group used dogs whose training programmes favoured punishment-based methods such as shouting or scolding. The two groups were filmed during their training.
The dog’s saliva was tested before and after to look for cortisol, the stress hormone. Their findings showed that dogs from the negative reinforcement group showed more signs of stress, lip licking and yawning.
However, dogs in the reward-based dog training groups showed almost no change in their cortisol levels. This was the same both when they were in the group and when they were at home with their owners.
Researchers also wanted to examine the long-term effects of the stress induced by punishment-based training. To do this, they measured how the dogs responded to food rewards.
They discovered that dogs from the reward-based training ran excitedly to the food bowl, but those from the punishment based training moved much more slowly towards the bowl and we unsure whether to take the food or not.
Speaking to Science Mag, the researchers said, “Reward-based training may take time, but so what? At least the dog isn’t living in fear or constant stress.”
In addition to this, Marc Bekoff, evolutionary biologist at the University of Colorado said of the study, “[Punishment] training may seem to work in the short run, but these methods can have future negative consequences. These dogs are living in perpetual stress.”